Importance/Relevance of Monitoring Site
The monitoring wells at this site were installed in 1993 and provide access for long-term measurements of groundwater level fluctuations and chemistry for the shallow system (water table within Halton Till) and the deep groundwater flow system (Thorncliffe aquifer complex) near regional groundwater discharge zones;
This site also provides monitoring information for the Lower Newmarket till which controls flow between the shallow and deep parts of the groundwater flow system; and
Observations made at this location continue to provide vital data that has led to an understanding of how groundwater flows in this area, an area characterized by a thick lower permeability glacial till unit in the subsurface.
The Duffins Creek watershed area has historically been part of many regional geologic and hydrogeologic investigations (Caley et al., 1947; Gadd, 1950; Hainstock et al., 1952; Karrow, 1967; Sibul et al., 1977; Ostry, 1979; Boyce, 1997; Gerber, 1999; Gerber and Howard, 2000; 2002; Li et al., 2008; Meriano and Eyles, 2009). The southern part of the watershed is the site of two now closed municipal waste landfills, and has seen numerous geological and hydrogeological investigations that were designed to assist in the siting of additional proposed landfill sites. During the early 1990s the Ontario Provincial Government set up the Interim Waste Authority (IWA) to site a landfill in each of Peel, Durham and York Regions. Some of the locations investigated within the north Pickering area, including Site EE11, are shown on Figure 1. Further information regarding the proposed IWA landfill sites shown on Figure 1 can be found in IWA, 1994a-e. The location of this site is also shown on Figure 2 and the regional geologic context is provided on the cross section included as Figure 3.
Groundwater measurements at the site were collected initially by M.M. Dillon Limited during 1993 and 1994 for IWA landfill siting investigations. Observations were continued by University of Toronto students and staff from 1996 to 2002. Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (two PGMN piezometers) and YPDT-CAMC staff have been collecting measurements from this site since 2009. Details regarding the seven monitoring wells installed on site are shown on Figure 4. Manual water level measurements are plotted since 1993 on a hydrograph that can be accessed below (see Documents).
Figure 1: Duffins Creek and Petticoat Creek watersheds showing locations of closed and some historical proposed municipal waste landfills. Site EE11 was a proposed landfill location during the IWA site search process during the early 1990s.
There are three major aquifer systems present within the watershed that occur within coarser grained sand and gravel sediments contained within the following geologic units:• The Oak Ridges Moraine/Mackinaw Interstadial (MIS);
• The Thorncliffe Formation; and
• The Scarborough Formation.
The bedrock beneath the watershed is shale and generally does not provide suitable groundwater yield or quality to form a water supply. More details on subsurface conditions encountered at this monitoring location are included in Sibul et al. (1977) and IWA (1994e).
This site provides groundwater observations for the till plain along the south slope of the Oak Ridges Moraine. It is also situated just north of the Glacial Lake Iroquois shoreline and just east of the deep creek valley along West Duffins Creek. The Glacial Lake Iroquois shoreline and deep valleys along rivers just north of Lake Ontario form major groundwater discharge areas. The base of the Duffins Creek valley just west of this site has been eroded down to deposits of the Thorncliffe Formation which contain the Thorncliffe aquifer complex (TAC).
Interesting items of note from the observed groundwater levels include:
Low Permeability• The long time period necessary for recovery to static water level for wells screened within the Lower Newmarket till. Piezometer EE11-1B is a 2″ diameter PVC piezometer installed within the Lower Newmarket till. Maintenance activities (pumping) lowered the water level in this piezometer in August 2012. Owing to the very low hydraulic conductivity/permeability of the Newmarket Till in this area, water can only move very slowly into the well and as a result, the groundwater level is still recovering to static two years later;
Variability in Newmarket Till• The entire thickness of the Lower Newmarket till does not function as a uniform aquitard. Previous studies have referred to this as an “aquitard thinning concept” where the greatest hydraulic head difference (as measured in wells screened above and below the till) occurs over the lowest hydraulic conductivity part of the till unit (DE5 and DE4 in the central part of the till unit; Figure 4). Structures such as sand seams and fractures in the top and bottom parts of the Newmarket till have been found to provide hydraulic connection to adjacent overlying and underlying aquifer units. Further discussion can be found in Gerber et al. (2001);
Underdraining to Duffins Creek• The vertical hydraulic gradient is a controlling factor in the direction and magnitude of groundwater flow between adjacent hydrostratigraphic units. The Lower Newmarket till, owing to its thickness and low hydraulic conductivity, separates the shallow part of the groundwater flow system from the deeper part and therefore largely controls the amount of groundwater flow that moves vertically downward to deeper aquifers in the Thorncliffe and Scarborough Formations. The vertical hydraulic gradient (groundwater flow driving force) through the Lower Newmarket till (thickness = 33.3m) at this site ranges between 0.75 and 0.80 downwards. This large vertical hydraulic gradient is interpreted to be caused by lateral drainage (discharge) from the Thorncliffe aquifer complex to the Duffins Creek valley situated to the west;
Seasonal Groundwater Fluctuations• The amplitude of the annual water table fluctuation within the Halton Till at this site is generally less than 2m. This amplitude of fluctuation is moderated by the location of this site near a local discharge area along the Lake Iroquois shoreline to the immediate south; and
• The amplitude of annual groundwater level variation within the Thorncliffe aquifer complex is approximately 1m, which is perhaps moderated because of this site’s proximity to a regional discharge area for the deep aquifer system along the Lake Iroquois shoreline and deep river valleys along the north shore of Lake Ontario. The amplitude of annual groundwater level variation within the Thorncliffe aquifer complex at site UofT Claremont further to the north away from the regional discharge area is a little over 2m; however, this amplitude may be partly affected by local groundwater pumping.
Figure 2: Duffins Creek watershed groundwater monitoring locations. North-south cross section (Figure 3) location shown in magenta.
Figure 3: North-south cross section through the Duffins Creek watershed showing location of IWA EE11-1 groundwater monitors.
Figure 4: Site IWA EE11-1 groundwater monitor details (Figure modified from Gerber et al., 2991). Piezometers A-F are 2” diameter PVC while W is 6” diameter steel. HT-Halton Till, Nt-Lower Newmarket till, TF-Thorncliffe Fm, Su-Sunnybrook Drift. Vibrating wire piezometers a-f no longer function.
Caley, J.F., T.H. Clark and E.B. Owen. 1947. Ground-Water Resources of Pickering Township, Ontario County, Ontario. Canada Department of Mines and Technical Surveys, Geological Survey of Canada, Water Supply Paper No. 285, 19p.
Boyce, J.I. 1997. Facies architecture and stratigraphic heterogeneity in glacial deposits and their relation to hydrogeologic function. Unpublished PhD thesis, Graduate Department of Geology, University of Toronto, 2203p.
Gadd, N.R. 1950. Ground-Water Resources of Uxbridge Township, Ontario County, Ontario. Canada Department of Mines and Technical Surveys, Geological Survey of Canada, Water Supply Paper No. 307, 23p.
Gerber, R.E. 1999. Hydrogeologic behaviour of the Northern till aquitard near Toronto, Ontario. Unpublished PhD thesis, Graduate Department of Geology, University of Toronto, 253p.
Gerber, R.E. and K.W.F. Howard. 1996. Evidence for recent groundwater flow through Late Wisconsinan till near Toronto, Ontario. Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 33, 538-555. Available athttp://www.nrcresearchpress.com/journal/cgj.
Gerber, R.E. and K.W.F. Howard. 2002. Hydrogeology of the Oak Ridges Moraine aquifer system: implications for protection and management from the Duffins Creek watershed. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 39, 1333-1348. Available at http://www.nrcresearchpress.com/journal/cjes.
Gerber, R.E. and K.W.F. Howard. 2000. Recharge through a regional till aquitard: three-dimensional flow model water balance approach. Ground Water 38, 410-422.
Gerber, R.E., J.I. Boyce and K.W.F. Howard. 2001. Evaluation of heterogeneity and field-scale groundwater flow regime in a leaky till aquitard. Hydrogeology Journal, 9(1), 60-78.
Hainstock, H.N., E.B. Owen and J.F. Caley. 1952. Ground-Water Resources of Whitchurch Township, Ontario County, Ontario. Canada Department of Mines and Technical Surveys, Geological Survey of Canada, Water Supply Paper No. 320, 25p.
Interim Waste Authority (1994a) EA document IV, geology/hydrogeology, technical appendix 1: Site T1 (P1) for Durham Region landfill site search. Prepared by M.M. Dillon Limited, February, 1994.
Interim Waste Authority (1994b) EA document IV, geology/hydrogeology, technical appendix 2: Site EE4 for Durham Region landfill site search. Prepared by M.M. Dillon Limited, February, 1994.
Interim Waste Authority (1994c) EA document IV, geology/hydrogeology, technical appendix 3: Site EE10 for Durham Region landfill site search. Prepared by M.M. Dillon Limited, February, 1994.
Interim Waste Authority (1994d) IWA landfill site search, Metro/York Region, Step 6 hydrogeological report Site M6. Prepared by Fenco MacLaren Inc, February 1994.
Interim Waste Authority (1994e) Detailed assessment of the proposed site EE11 for Durham Region landfill site search, Technical appendices Parts 1 and 3 of 4. Prepared by M.M. Dillon Limited, October 1994.
Karrow, P.F. 1967. Pleistocene Geology of the Scarborough Area. Ontario Department of Mines, Geological Report 46.
Li, Q., A.J.A. Unger, E.A. Sudicky, D. Kassenaar, E.J. Wexler and S. Shikaze. 2008. Simulating the multi-seasonal response of a large-scale watershed with a 3D physically-based hydrologic model. Journal of Hydrology, 357, 317-336.
Meriano, M. and N. Eyles. 2009. Quantitative assessment of the hydraulic role of subglaciofluvial interbeds in promoting deposition of deformation till (Northern Till, Ontario). Quaternary Science Reviews 28, 608-620.
Ostry, R.C. 1979. The Hydrogeology of the IFYGL Duffins Creek Study Area. Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Water Resources Branch, Water Resources Report 5c, 39p.
Piggott, A. 1999. Data Restoration for the Historic Ontario Ministry of the Environment Network of Observation Wells. National Water Research Institute Contribution Number 99-245.
Sibul, U., K.T. Wang and D. Vallery. 1977. Ground-Water Resources of the Duffins Creek-Rouge River Drainage Basins. Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Water Resources Branch, Water Resources Report 8, 109p.